We'd been in Peter Fox's studio in Mt. Pleasant, D.C., tracking with Peter and Doug, just trying to crank out a quick little Christmas present for the LTH fans of the world. It was July, 2000, I believe. So we'd tracked the drums and bass in one day, five tracks in all ("Home for Christmas," "Christmas," "White Christmas," "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas," and "I've Got My Love to Keep Me Warm"). I was thinking of a $10 CD, and thought that we needed one more song to justify that price. (This was before Scott offered his amazing and weird and beautiful banjo carol interludes, and before Kevin had done his cool horn fanfare as track #2). Martin had his drums all packed up, and the thought of loading all of it back into that basement at some point to record another tune didn't strike anyone's fancy. ML said, "Why don't you write another song, one that's just acoustic and doesn't need drums?" Hmmmm. Well, okay. So I went home that night, and I strummed a C chord, and the words, "We strung the lights on Christmas eve" came out of my mouth. I thought, "who strung lights???" It's like that sometimes when you write a song. There's something happening, and you don't know what it is. So I let the story tell itself. It came to me quickly: A party with some old friends, some new friends, some pizza, up in Minnesota. Where's Otis Lane? I looked online at a map of St. Paul to find a road that could possibly have a view over the Mississippi river. That one looked likely. Later on, Scott McKnight sent me a satellite photo of the area, and it seems like it *could* have a view of the river, but I've never confirmed it. Someone else told me that Otis Lane was in a pretty swank neighborhood and that it was unlikely to be the site of a group house. So in my head, it's become a really nice big house... the owners are away on Anguilla, and have let their 20-something daughter have a Christmas party there. Martin often has an "Orphan's Thanksgiving," and I reckon that was in the back of my head somewhere. We strung the lights on New Years Eve
Then sat around and drank
So-called orphans by choice and circumstance
At the old house on Otis Lane
The eggnog was weak but the punch was strong
It got stronger as the night wore on
We called out for pizza
Jenny cut a star from the cardboard box
Santa, come to St. Paul
We're waiting up for you
The lights on the tree, they shine in every color
But it's hard to not be blue
Jenny climbed a chair with the star in her hand
To put it on top of the tree
She fell over but she was okay
You could hear her laugh for blocks away
Started talking to a friend of Eileen's
She'd driven all the way from Madison
Turns out she really was an orphan
She was nervous when i held her hand
Santa, come to St. Paul
We're waiting up for you
the lights on the tree they shine in every color
And the ice on the river is blue
We stepped out side and I finally asked her name
I liked it when she said "Susannah"
I asked if she had plans for New Years Eve
She said "I've always hated New Years Eve"
The Mississippi river reflected the stars
It was dark, and hard to see her face
I think she smiled and I know she kissed me
And said "Let's call tonight our New Years Eve"
Santa, come to St. Paul
We're waiting up for you
The lights on the tree they shine in every color
And Susannah's eyes are blue
Santa come to St. Paul
We're waiting up for you
The lights on the tree they shine in every color
Susannah, don't be blue
Now, the year is new
Susannah, don't be blue